Every defence works. The question is what each one costs, and the cost is
never the price on the packet.
Ranked, best first
- Nematodes. Expensive, needs warm wet soil, and works. Six weeks of cover
per application, so three applications a season if you mean it. - Beer traps. Cheap, effective within about a metre, and you have to empty
them, which is genuinely unpleasant. - Copper tape. Works on pots and only on pots, and stops working the moment a
leaf bridges the rim. - Night patrols with a torch. Free, effective, and it costs you the evening.
- Pellets. I do not use them, because the plot has hedgehogs.
What does not work
- Crushed eggshells
- Coffee grounds
- Wool pellets, in my soil, though people I trust swear by them
- Hoping
The thing that changed most
Not a defence at all: raising transplants to a decent size before they go out.
A slug can strip a two-leaf seedling in a night. It can only annoy a plant
with six leaves and a root system.
This season’s plan
- Nematodes in the brassica bed, mid-May
- Beer traps around the hostas, refilled weekly
- Nothing at all for the beans, which have never once been touched
- A torch by the shed door
The ledger entry I keep forgetting
Slug damage is worst in the week after transplanting and almost irrelevant a
month later. Everything on this list is really a way of buying one week.
last updated: